JEWISHNESS AND THE PROBLEM OF NATIONALISM: A GENEALOGY OF ARENDT'S EARLY POLITICAL THOUGHT

Abstract

<jats:p>Hannah Arendt's early writings, focused on Jewish politics in the 1930s and 1940s, are in many ways her most directly political work. Yet certain problematic concepts in these texts, notably the idea of the “Jewish nation,” have led many to disregard it. A shift in the themes of Arendt's work following the publication of <jats:italic>The Origins of Totalitarianism</jats:italic> in 1951 has resulted in further divisions being drawn between the pre- and post-<jats:italic>Origins</jats:italic> work. This essay opposes both these positions. By mapping out the causes and development of Arendt's thought on the “Jewish nation,” in particular through her critical engagement with Zionism and her support of a binational or federal political solution in Israel and Palestine, the influence of Arendt's early thought on Jewish politics is shown to form the basis of a more general theory of politics, further developed in her later work on the nature of the political.</jats:p>